While we were wandering around in Nolensville, we decided to stop at the Nolensville Feed Mill.
The big sign that said “Bread, Pies and Cakes” just pulled us right in.
When we walked in the door, we were immediately impressed with the variety of foods that they carried. They had Noble Springs Diary Goat Cheese, Hatcher Family Dairy Milk, Yoder Brothers Meats, farm fresh eggs, a variety of jams and jellies, fresh baked breads including sourdough, wheat, and rosemary garlic bread. We were very excited about the eggs and the variety of meats. Our CSA ends in November and we are hooked on farm fresh eggs and the meats from Yoder Farms. It’s nice to know there will be a place we can continue to feed our addiction.
Cary had the “The Mill” sandwich filled with Troyer cheese and both turkey and corned beef. Disregard the large bite that was taken out of the sandwich. Most of the time I can get a picture of the food before Cary tries it, but the sandwich was just too good.
You can also buy meat by the pound. We were very excited to find out it is cheaper than either Publix or Kroger, about $5.99 (variable).
The chicken salad was full of tender chicken, pecans, celery, and dried cranberries. They also offered a chicken salad with grapes in lieu of cranberries. I tried both and opted for the cranberry version. It was served on the homemade sourdough bread, which was incredibly soft, with lettuce and tomatoes.
We were delighted to find Sprecher Gourmet Sodas. They had cream soda, root beer, lo-cal root beer, cherry cola, orange dream and ginger ale.
While we were there, Young Republic performed one last song that quickly turned into three because the audience begged. They were great. Look them up on Myspace or iTunes.
There was a variety of Mrs. Armstrong’s Fried Pies. This is the peach. Don’t let the picture fool you. It was delicious. They also have cherry, apricot, chocolate, apple and coconut. We tried several varieties throughout the week. They had buttery, flakey crusts and just plain good fruit filling.
They have a variety of sweets. While we were there, we tried the banana nut bread, which was fantastic. We brought home miniature chocolate chess and chess pies. If baked goods aren’t your thing, they also had Pied Piper ice cream.
Some friends of our suggested we bring the caramel puffcorn home. They said it was addictive like crack… and boy howdy, were they right (not that I know anything about crack). It was sweet, light and crispy.
We really can’t say enough about The Mill. It was open, airy, clean and organized. Not only did they sell many great food products, we also had fun wandering through their collection of antiques for sale. When we left Cary said that he had finally found a great sandwich place in Nashville.
Amish Market at the Mill7280 Nolensville Rd
Nolensville, TN 37135











Wow! I’ll have to tell my husband since he’s a huge fan of Sprecher sodas. We always get some when we’re in Wisconsin.
What a coincidence, I just went to the Nolensville Feed Mill this past weekend. My old buddy from H.S. from my Boston days was down in Nashville for a conference and wanted to see me and her old buddies who own the NFM. Anyway, it is a cute store, and they carry some Heini’s cheese, which I like the Bermuda onion cheddar. NFM doesn’t normally carry that variety, but they are ordering that special for me. the Bermuda onion cheese will be in on Sept 5, so go get yourself some.
Ooooo…. We’ll have to try it!
Was shopping in Mt. Juliet Ross’ and another customer from Nolensville told me to return to the Feed Mill and sample their chicken salad – it was so delish ! Field trip !!
You are always acknowledged right away w/a big smile & feel so welcome..I started going there soon as they opened & have watched it develop….a great addition for a little town that I have so many fond memories of from my childhood
Hi… I’m the old BUDDY from Boston that Lannae (above) was talking about and I had a blast visiting with everyone last week (I live in Florida) – I love visiting the Mill and sending my friends there ’cause my long-time friend Darin and his family have a GREAT Amish Market. This time, my friends and I were first greeted by owner Darin’s rendition of his new song “BFF” — and that’s what it boils down to. Everyone who walks into the AMISH MARKET AT THE MILL is greeted like a LONG TIME FRIEND!!!!
Sit down, drink some coffee, have a “sammich”, stock up on delicious and unique products, enjoy some music, what have you been up to? Didn’t we see you here before? When you visit the Mill — you are HOME!
So stop by today and tell them JUST JAX sent ya!
And HI LANAE and AUDREY! ♥ ♥ Darin, Linda, Cindy — Hugs to you all!